Round 1
- Sled Dogs – LB Koby Quansah
- Mastodons – DL Zach Brug
- Wings – DB Kieron Williams
- Centipedes – DB Jeremiah Johnson
Round 2
- Mastodons – K Louie Zervos
- Wings – LB Davis Tull
- Centipedes – LB Connor Harris
- Sled Dogs – LB Javahn Fergurson
Round 3
- Wings – OL Anthony DeBella
- Centipedes – WR Noah Wanzek
- Sled Dogs – DB Elmore Hempstead Jr
- Mastodons – DB Danny Robinson
Round 4
- Centipedes – K Wesley Rubiera
- Sled Dogs – LB Joe Piatnik
- Mastodons – DL Hunter Dimick
- Wings – RB Prescott Line
Round 5
- Sled Dogs – QB Kelly Bryant
- Mastodons – WR Matt Seybert
- Wings – RB Wesley Schools
- Centipedes – DB Jeremiah McKinnon
Round 6
- Mastodons – OL Zachary Heren
- Wings – DL Stansly Maponga
- Centipedes – DL Sealver Siliga
- Sled Dogs – WR Layne Bieberle
Round 7
- Wings – OL Dwayne Wallace
- Centipedes – LB Fitzgerald Mofor
- Sled Dogs – WR Cole Rotenberry
- Mastodons – WR PJ Meyer
Round 8
- Centipedes – OL Dante Reynolds
- Sled Dogs – WR Jake Peterson
- Mastodons – OL Shane Fudge
- Wings – LB Terence Garvin
Round 9
- Sled Dogs – DL Alec DiValerio
- Mastodons – LB Clay Shreve
- Wings – QB Riley Ferguson
- Centipedes – OL Kenneth Trezvant
Round 10
- Mastodons – QB Austin Simmons
- Wings – WR Tyler Palka
- Centipedes – QB Jalen Morton
- Sled Dogs – DL Justin Shanks
Round 11
- Wings – DB Corey Stefanik
- Centipedes – RB Dexter McCluster
- Sled Dogs – OL Wyatt French
- Mastodons – RB Marc Meislahn
Round 12
- Centipedes – WR Ryan Skibinski
- Sled Dogs – OL Tyler Drob
- Mastodons – OL Tyler Davis
- Wings – OL Justin Cook
Round 13
- Sled Dogs – WR Max Linder
- Mastodons – DL David Gajderowicz
- Wings – DL Jared Harris
- Centipedes – DB Khalil Brooks
Round 14
- Mastodons – WR Nate Couturier
- Wings – DB Nic Hover
- Centipedes – DB Drew Daniel
- Sled Dogs – QB TJ Edwards II
Round 15
- Wings – LB Chris Worley
- Centipedes – DB Richard Sheler
- Sled Dogs – DB Hasan Sharif
- Mastodons – WR Vinny Gregory
Round 16
- Centipedes – DB Ka’Lonn Milton
- Sled Dogs – DL Tymir Oliver
- Mastodons – DB Jamal Parker
- Wings – OL David Niehaus
Round 17
- Sled Dogs – LB Brad Zaffram
- Mastodons – LB Brody Grantham
- Wings – WR Dylan Brewer
- Centipedes – DL Deion Barnes
Round 18
- Mastodons – DL Nico Lautanen
- Wings – K Ryan Anderson
- Centipedes – DL Saif Khan
- Sled Dogs – LB Jamal Ware
Round 19
- Wings – DL Cameron Brown
- Centipedes – DL Tre’ Hornbuckle
- Sled Dogs – RB Tyler McCloskey
- Mastodons – DB Brendan Holmes
Round 20
- Centipedes – LB Tristian Green
- Sled Dogs – RB Ed Ilnicki
- Mastodons – LB Alex Ney
- Wings – RB De’Shawn Waller
Round 21
- Sled Dogs – WR Shawn Clark
- Mastodons – RB Joe Fitzpatrick
- Wings – DB Demetrius Boyd
- Centipedes – LB Marcus Johnson
Round 22
- Mastodons – QB Jake Maier
- Wings – WR Chris Ellington
- Centipedes – LB Demetrius Bernard
- Sled Dogs – DB Parker Gregston
Round 23
- Wings – OL Jake Bull
- Centipedes – OL Jamar Dorival
- Sled Dogs – OL Travis Krall
- Mastodons – DB Brennan Sefick
Round 24
- Centipedes – OL Howard Bush
- Sled Dogs – OL Brandon Schindler
- Mastodons – WR Kyle Haines
- Wings – QB Ed Crouch
Round 25
- Sled Dogs – LB Garrett Dooley
- Mastodons – OL Rich Kelly
- Wings – DL Shahaun Williams
- Centipedes – QB Ross Comis
Round 26
- Mastodons – RB Brodie Frederiksen
- Wings – DB Ayron Monroe
- Centipedes – RB Walter Fletcher
- Sled Dogs – DL Kevin Kavalec
Round 27
- Wings – LB Raphael Garner
- Centipedes – WR Terrance Bynum
- Sled Dogs – QB Quinton Maxwell
- Mastodons – K Chase Vinatieri
Round 28
- Centipedes – WR Jacob Hill
- Sled Dogs – DB DaQuaun Jamison
- Mastodons – QB Kevin Anderson
- Wings – WR Jordan McCray
Round 29
- Sled Dogs – RB I’Tavius Mathers
- Mastodons – DB Joey LaMore
- Wings – OL Jordan Johnson
- Centipedes – Pass
Round 30
- Mastodons – LB Jimmy Bauer
- Wings – DB Rion Davis
- Centipedes – Pass
- Sled Dogs – DB Terik Miller
Round 31
- Wings – RB Detrez Newsome
- Centipedes – Pass
- Sled Dogs – DB Cameron Watkins
- Mastodons – DL Brady Opp
Round 32
- Centipedes – Pass
- Sled Dogs – QB Johnny Feauto
- Mastodons – QB Jace Hammack
- Wings – QB Koy Detmer Jr
Round 33
- Sled Dogs – K Davan Dyer
- Mastodons – OL Kirk Kelley
- Wings – K Griffin Trau
- Centipedes – Pass